There is a particular kind of person who rewatches the same handful of films every October and can tell you which cut of each one is the right cut. Buying for them looks easy from the outside — the genre has more merchandise than almost any other — and it is not.
The problem is that horror is a dozen fandoms wearing one coat. The Hereditary crowd and the Friday the 13th crowd overlap far less than the shelf at the store suggests. So this list is sorted by what a gift actually is — something to display, something to play, something to read, something to use — with a note on who each one is really for.
We may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.
Our Top Picks
Three that work for nearly any horror fan, if you would rather not read the whole list.
Super7 Supersize Coraline 16-Inch Figure
The showpiece — big enough to read as an object rather than a toy.
Ravensburger Horrified: Universal Monsters
The one that gets a mixed group to sit down and play together.
Pop Chart 100 Horror Movies Scratch-Off Poster
The safe bet: wall art and a year of viewing assignments at once.
Before You Buy
One thing worth checking before you buy: horror fandom is narrower than it looks from outside it. Someone who loves Hereditary may have no interest at all in a Jason figure, and a slasher completist can find A24 films unbearably slow — so if all you know is that they like scary movies, lean on the gifts that span the whole genre rather than anything welded to a single franchise. Two practical notes on top of that: a sixteen-inch figure needs somewhere to live, and most of the games below are exclusive to one console, so find out what is actually plugged into their television first.
Figures, Plush and Props
The shelf category. Three that earn their space, and six smaller ones that do not ask for much.
THE SHOWPIECE
Super7 Supersize Coraline 16-Inch Figure
Super7’s Supersize line builds figures at sixteen inches instead of the usual six, and the Coraline is the one that stops reading as a toy and starts reading as an object. The fabric clothing is what sells it up close. It needs a shelf of its own, so this is a gift for someone with room to give it, not for a crowded desk.
BEST SMALL COLLECTIBLE
Funko Pop! Ghostface, Glow in the Dark
Almost every horror character has a Funko by now, which is exactly why this is the one worth singling out: the glow-in-the-dark finish is the variant collectors go looking for, and it is an Amazon exclusive rather than a shelf staple. Small enough to be a stocking stuffer and still feel chosen.
BEST PROP FOR A SHELF
Hellraiser Lament Configuration Puzzle Box Prop
The Lament Configuration is the rare horror prop that works as an object even for people who have not seen the films — a small carved cube that guests pick up and turn over. The panels detach, which is most of the fun. It is sold as a cosplay prop rather than a screen-accurate replica, so think of it as decor with a good story.
Stranger Things Demogorgon 12-Inch Feature Plush
Twelve inches of Demogorgon with a head that opens and sound effects — the Stranger Things gift for someone who is not precious about display.
Funko Pop! They Live Alien
A They Live alien for the John Carpenter obsessive. Styles vary, so which one turns up is part of the gift.
Epic Collectibles Annabelle Comes Home Vinyl Figure
An Annabelle figure from the Conjuring end of the genre, for a fan whose taste runs to haunted objects.
One Wish Willow Stick and Box Prop Set
The One Wish Willow stick and its box from the film Obsession, made as a display prop rather than a collector’s piece — it is built for a shelf or a party table rather than close inspection.
Horror Movie Character Duck, 3.5-Inch Resin
A 3.5-inch resin duck in the pinstripe suit and bat bow tie of a certain long-faced skeleton. Unofficial, and funnier for it.
Handmade Horror Water Lamp
A hockey-masked figure in chains, sealed in a lit glass jar on a gravel lakebed. A bedside lamp for someone who would rather not be soothed.
Games for the Table
Horror is better with other people in the room. These range from a full cooperative board game to a deck you can hand someone cold.
BEST GAME FOR A GROUP
Ravensburger Horrified: Universal Monsters
Horrified is cooperative, and that is why it works on a mixed table: everyone plays against the Universal Monsters together instead of against each other. You choose how many monsters to take on, so the difficulty scales to who showed up, and it plays solo as well as with five. The easiest game here to talk a room of non-horror people into.
Funko Games Scream The Game
A party game for three to eight built around the phone call — best with a loud group and a short attention span.
Halloween 1978 The Board Game
A board game set in Haddonfield on the night of the original film, aimed at people who know it shot for shot.
Binge-Watch Bingo: Horror
Bingo cards of horror tropes to play against whatever is already on — the low-commitment option for a movie night.
Poorly Explained Movies: Horror Edition
Trivia built on deliberately terrible plot summaries, and funnier the more horror the guesser has actually sat through.
Universal Monsters Tarot Deck and Guidebook
A full 78-card deck with a guidebook, illustrated with the classic Universal monsters — a gift even for someone who does not read cards.
Classic Horror Oracle Deck
An oracle deck drawn from classic horror imagery. Shorter and looser than tarot, so it is easier to hand to a beginner.
Horror on the Console
Four to play, each on a different kind of night. Check which console is in the house before you buy any of them.
THE NEW RELEASE
Halloween: The Game for PlayStation 5
The newest Halloween adaptation here, and the most straightforward console gift for someone who already owns a PS5 — a current-generation release rather than a back-catalogue title they may have to hunt for. PlayStation 5 only, so confirm the console before you buy.
FOR THE CLIVE BARKER FAN
Clive Barker’s Hellraiser: Revival for PlayStation 5
Clive Barker’s name is on this one, which matters more to this audience than it would to most — Hellraiser fans tend to care who is involved. Also PlayStation 5 only, and a better fit for the fan who liked the source material than for a casual player.
BEST FOR A GROUP ONLINE
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre for PlayStation 5
The Texas Chainsaw take on asymmetric multiplayer — one side hunting, the other side hiding — which makes it the pick for someone whose friends play together rather than alone. Built for current-generation PlayStation.
THE ONE THAT IS ACTUALLY FUN
RetroRealms Double Feature: Halloween and Ash vs Evil Dead
Halloween and Ash vs Evil Dead rebuilt as two linked 16-bit side-scrollers in a single package, and the least punishing thing in this section — closer to an arcade game than a survival horror. This is the Nintendo Switch edition, which is also the best of the three for playing handheld. The same double feature is on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X if that is the box they own.
Books, Screenplays and Coloring Books
Where the genre gets taken seriously, and where it gets taken least seriously. Both are represented.
BEST COFFEE TABLE BOOK
The Art of Horror Movies: An Illustrated History
An illustrated history built around poster art, lobby cards and production stills rather than criticism, which is what makes it the book guests pick up. It is the safest book here: it works for the fan who has read everything and for the one who mostly likes how the genre looks.
FOR THE PRACTICAL-EFFECTS OBSESSIVE
Making Monsters: Inside Stories from Hollywood’s Creature Creators
Interviews and behind-the-scenes accounts from the people who physically built Hollywood’s monsters. This is for the fan who pauses films to study the seams, and it is a good match for anyone who works in production themselves.
BEST NOVEL
The Final Girl Support Group by Grady Hendrix
Grady Hendrix’s novel about slasher survivors decades after their films, doing for the final-girl trope roughly what Scream did for the rules. The pick for someone who actually reads, rather than another object for an already full shelf.
World War Z Deluxe Slipcase Edition
The oral-history zombie novel in a slipcase edition — an upgrade gift for someone who already owns the paperback.
Nightmare Autopsis: A Return to Elm Street
A deep dive back through the Elm Street films, for the Freddy completist rather than the newcomer.
The Definitive Guide to Horror Movies
A reference-style survey of the genre, and therefore something to argue with. Good for a fan who likes ranking things.
Your Favorite Scary Movie: How Scream Rewrote the Rules
A history of how the Scream films changed what horror was allowed to know about itself, for the meta-horror crowd.
Midsommar Screenplay Book
Ari Aster’s screenplay in book form, for the elevated-horror reader who wants the text rather than the commentary.
Hereditary Screenplay Book
The Hereditary script as a companion volume — the obvious pair with the Midsommar book, and better as a set.
Haunted Dolls Coloring Book
Coloring pages of haunted dolls, an idea specific enough to be funny on its own as a small gift.
Classic Horror Movies Coloring Book
The same idea pointed at the Universal-era monsters, for the classicist in the group.
Haunted Dolls Sticker Book
A sticker book from the same line — the smallest thing on this list, and useful filler for a stocking.
Decor That Commits to the Bit
Two that can stay up all year, and six that are honest about being seasonal.
BEST LIGHTING
Paladone Pennywise Red Balloon Lamp
An officially licensed accent lamp shaped like Pennywise’s red balloon — specific enough to be recognised instantly, abstract enough to leave up in November. It is mood lighting for a corner rather than something to read by, which is the right expectation to set.
THE CONVERSATION PIECE
The Original Bloody Bath Mat
The mat that shows red footprints when it gets wet and fades back to plain as it dries. It is a prank gift that happens to also be a functioning bath mat, which is why it tends to survive past Halloween when most novelty items do not.
Paladone Beetlejuice Icon Accent Light
A licensed Beetlejuice accent light — smaller and softer than the Pennywise lamp, and mild enough to work as a nightlight.
The Overlook Hotel Vintage Travel Poster, 16×24
A vintage-travel-poster treatment of the Overlook. The one piece here that passes as ordinary wall art until you read it.
Pop Chart 100 Horror Movies Scratch-Off Poster
Scratch off each film as they watch it: part wall art, part a year of viewing assignments.
Estmy Gothic Skeleton Halloween Shower Curtain Set
Waffle-fabric curtain in skulls and bats with hooks included, for someone whose whole bathroom is already the bit.
Chia Pet Ghost Face Planter
A Ghost Face Chia Pet, exactly as advertised, terracotta planter and seed pack included. No further explanation is available or necessary. There is also a Friday the 13th Jason version if that is the more reliable laugh in their house.
Vintage Gothic Horror Movie Wall Art, 14×11
A vintage-styled gothic horror print, unframed at 14 by 11 inches, so they can frame it the way they want. Unlicensed and non-specific, which is the point — it hangs in a room where a character poster would be too much.
Small Gifts and Stocking Stuffers
Nothing here asks for shelf space, and nothing here needs explaining at the door.
Camp Crystal Lake Counselor Trucker Cap
Reads as a plain retro trucker hat right up until someone catches the reference — wearable in daylight, and a quiet test of who is paying attention.
Handbook for the Recently Deceased Enamel Pin
An enamel pin of the Beetlejuice handbook. Costs very little, lands hard with the right person, and goes on a jacket or a bag.
Georgie’s Paper Boat Wooden Ornament
Georgie’s paper boat engraved into wood rather than printed — subtle enough to survive being hung on a family tree without a conversation.
Bates Motel Vintage Keychain Fob, Black
A heavy vintage motel fob for the Bates Motel: the Psycho pick, and pleasingly useless as anything but a keychain.
Overlook Hotel Vintage Keychain Fob, Red
The same fob in red for the Overlook. Buy both if they cannot be trusted to choose a hotel.
Tree Buddees Creepy Twins Ornaments
The Shining’s twins as tree ornaments, which covers Halloween and Christmas in a single purchase.
Jason Horror Movie Birthday Card
A horror-themed birthday card, for when the real gift needs something to sit on top of.
Overlook Carpet Kiss-Lock Card Holder
The Overlook’s carpet from The Shining, as a kiss-lock pouch sized for cards and ID. The rare horror gift someone carries every day.
Aquarius Chucky Good Guys Tin Storage Box
A licensed Child’s Play tin with an embossed lid — useful as storage, and better still as the thing you wrap the smaller gifts inside.
What We Do in the Shadows Lazlo and Nadja Pendant Necklace
A pendant on a 24-inch chain for Lazlo and Nadja, the vampire housemates from the TV series rather than the film it grew out of.
Pulp Frankenstein Bumper Sticker Decal, 5-Inch
A five-inch decal crossing pulp paperback cover art with Frankenstein’s monster. For a laptop lid, a water bottle, or an actual bumper.
Freddy Krueger Glove Stainless Steel Chopsticks
Stainless steel chopsticks with the bladed glove for handles, and officially licensed, which very little Elm Street merchandise at this size is. The only gift on this list that gets used at dinner and still makes the point.
For a Horror Movie Night
The hosting shelf: something to drink out of, something to put the drink on, and something to put on in the background.
BEST HOSTING GIFT
Cocktails from the Crypt Recipe Book
Cocktail recipes themed to horror films, which quietly turns a gift into an activity — the one thing on this list that gives someone something to do on the night rather than something more to own. It pairs with everything else in this section, which is not an accident.
Silver Buffalo Beetlejuice Here Lies Grave Mug, 20oz
A 20oz sculpted mug shaped like Beetlejuice’s grave marker — the most substantial of the three mugs here.
Silver Buffalo Chucky Good Guys Mug, 22oz
A 22oz sculpted Chucky mug with a shaped handle. Bigger than the Beetlejuice one, and rather harder to wash around.
Equoza Gothic Scream Coffee Mug, 11oz
A plain printed 11oz mug rather than a sculpted one, which makes it the everyday-use option of the three.
The Shining Overlook Carpet Throw Blanket, 50×40
The carpet from outside room 237 as a couch-sized throw. To anyone who has not seen the film it just reads as bold retro geometry.
Horror Movie Character Coaster Set with Holder
Six character coasters and a holder, which is the set that makes a coffee table look deliberate rather than cluttered.
Anthology: Movie Themes 1974-1998 Soundtrack
John Carpenter’s own re-recordings of his film themes. This is the soundtrack for everything else in this section.